Old-Fashioned Butter Rolls

Name: Old-Fashioned Butter Rolls
Prep time: 15 min
Cook time: 40 min
Total time: 55 min
Ingredients: 2 cups self-rising flour; 1/2 cup shortening; 1/2 cup milk; 1 stick butter, softened (can use margarine); 1/4 cup sugar; 1 teaspoon cinnamon; 2 cups milk; 2/3 cups sugar; 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

This old-fashioned butter rolls recipe is something else. A Southern dessert specialty, it includes tender and moist cinnamon-spiced rolls in a creamy sweet custard-like sauce.

Jump to Recipe

Some of our most beloved Southern dishes begin with flour. Biscuits, milk gravy, chicken and dumplings, and today’s recipe: old-fashioned butter rolls. I wish I could say I’d grown up eating butter rolls but the truth is I had this dessert for the first time about 10 years ago, thanks to my Grandmama.

So, what is a butter roll? Trust me when I say, it’s like heaven on a plate. If that isn’t a good enough description, its closest relative is a cinnamon roll. However, it’s baked in a rich homemade custard sauce that stays just runny enough to be considered kind of a custard gravy of sorts. They’re ooey-gooey, tender, and absolutely delicious. Oh Lawd, you need to make these.

Fortunately, they’re a relatively easy dessert to whip together using everyday ingredients like milk, sugar, flour, cinnamon, and butter, of course. By the way, like so many of my other dessert recipes on Southern Plate, you can use Splenda in this one. Just remember that the key to cutting down on the artificially sweetened taste is to use just a hair less than the recipe calls for (remove one or two tablespoons per cup) and be sure you don’t pack it. Splenda should be measured out light and fluffy.

After you give this butter roll recipe a go, feel free to use your favorite biscuit dough or even experiment with canned biscuits. It’s really easy and fuss-free. You may also enjoy this version using a shortcut (also known as Crescent Rolls).

Before we get baking, I have a favor to ask. Since this is a nearly forgotten recipe of days gone by, help me bring it back again so it won’t be lost to future generations. If you enjoy it, please pass this recipe for old-fashioned butter rolls on.

Recipe Ingredients

Milk
Sugar
Self-rising flour
Vanilla extract
Shortening
Cinnamon
Butter at room temperature

How to Make Old-Fashioned Butter Rolls

Place your flour in a large bowl along with the shortening.

Cut shortening in with a fork…

until combined well, like this.

Pour in your milk.

Stir well.

Spray your pan.

You don’t have to do this but I was in the mood.

Put some flour on a clean countertop or wherever you feel like doing this.

You can use whatever biscuit dough is your favorite or just go by this recipe. This one is gonna hold up a little better in our sauce because it’s a little drier.

Press it together to form a ball.

Then pat it out with your hands a bit and roll it out into a rectangle-type object.

Notice I didn’t get too particular here. This is an old-fashioned Southern dessert and I figure Granny was busy with kids underfoot and hungry folks marching in the door. Back in those days folks cooked their food, not built a shrine to it.

Now we’re gonna smear our butter on the rolled-out biscuit dough.

All y’all who are on the real butter bandwagon need to give me my gold star today :).

Generously sprinkle all of our sugar over it.

Then comes the cinnamon, just a hint.

The dough and sauce mixed together with the butter and vanilla are going to have the most lovely flavor on their own!

Now roll that up.

Cut it in about one-inch slices (one inch-ish).

Remember, this is old-fashioned food. It’s not supposed to look a certain way, it’s just supposed to taste good.

Place your old-fashioned butter rolls into the prepared baking dish.

Now it’s time to make the sauce!

Add the milk to a saucepan, along with…

The sugar and…

The vanilla extract.

Stir that over low to medium heat until the milk is hot and the sugar dissolves.

Pour the milk sauce over your old-fashioned butter rolls.

Oh my.

I hope you’ve tasted the sauce by now.

If you haven’t, go ahead, I won’t look. ~covers eyes and grins~

Bake at 350 for about 30 to 40 minutes, until golden brown on top.

Grab one of your butter rolls, place it on a plate to serve, and…

Spoon more sauce on them. Enjoy real old-fashioned goodness, from Granny’s kitchen to yours.

Storage

These butter rolls definitely taste the best hot out of the oven. But if you do have leftovers, you can store them in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 4 days. The roll might get soggy sitting in the sauce, so I’d recommend reheating in the oven to crisp it up once more.

Recipe Notes

To make your own self-rising flour, see my FAQ page. Speaking of, I use a lot of both plain and self-rising flour at my house and have been known to dump whatever I grabbed first into my flour canister when it got empty. Sometimes I lose track of what is in there and need to know if it’s plain or self-rising. There is an easy fix. Dip your finger into the flour and lick it. If it tastes salty, it is self-rising. If it tastes bland, it is plain. I have to do this at least once a week but I’m perfectly alright with that because I decided long ago that being disorganized was just part of my charm. ~grins~
If you don’t have shortening on hand, you can substitute it for an equal amount of butter.
You can also substitute the ground cinnamon for ground nutmeg, or use a pinch of each.
For something different, add some finely chopped apple, raisins, or chopped nuts to the filling.

You may also enjoy these other delectable old-fashioned dessert recipes:

Ole Fashioned Southern Sugar Plum Cake

Old-Fashioned Rhubarb Crisp

Peanut Butter Pie Made the Old-Fashioned Way

Homemade Chocolate Pudding, Southern-Style

Lemon Icebox Cake

Easy Old-Fashioned Peach Cobbler Recipe