Cream Cheese Divinity

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Cream Cheese Divinity - A new no-fail take on Divinity! You won't believe how easy this is!

Cream Cheese Divinity is my own creation, born out of my love for traditional divinity!

I love traditional Southern Divinity, the holidays just aren’t the same without it. Mama and I both make up batches and divvy it out like it was gold doubloons among our families and friends. It’s just that good.

So here is the thing, this recipe is not traditional divinity. I didn’t develop it to be that. I developed it to be an awful lot like it but simple for anyone to make and good in its own right. 

Will it remind you of divinity? Definitely. But this is decadently wonderful in it’s own special way.

Think of how good that cream cheese icing tastes, especially when you get a bite that has a big pecan on it. Now you have some understanding what this is going to be like – only a good bit better.

Guess what else though? This recipe doesn’t depend on the weather, or temperature of your house, or how your pinkie toes are crossed to make it. There is no thermometer needed, no syrup to be made, and nothing hot to burn yourself on. You toss all of the ingredients into a mixing bowl and mix. Then, roll it into balls and press a pecan into the center. That’s it. Seriously!

But before I get into that, I have to share a conversation we all (the Southern Plate family) had yesterday on Facebook. I asked folks to post encouraging scripture passages that meant a lot to them or helped to lift them up and goodness gracious, did y’all deliver (Click here to see that post)!

I plan on printing them out later today to tape up on my wall but I haven’t had time to sit down and really go through them all. These are the kinds of things you want to read word for word, when you can really focus on what they are saying.

I had to share with you one that immediately jumped out at me though! Delaine Carr quoted a verse that I have kept close to my heart for the past several years. In fact, if you ever see any old television programs with me on them you might notice a small silver band on my right hand where I had this verse engraved. I don’t have that ring now because a few years back I happened upon someone who needed it more than I did at the time. But despite the verse being dear to me as it was, it was Delaine’s spin on it that really jumped out because I’d never heard it put that way before but it made perfect sense!

She said: “Be still and know that I am God. ~Psalm 46:10 This verse has always given me comfort! My version is ‘Hush! Let me handle this!'”

How many times in my life have I needed to be told that by God? I couldn’t begin to count them if I tried. But I thought I’d share that with you today with a reminder that He still has us in His hand. Oftentimes, things go easier for us if we’d simply stop being our own biggest impediment. 🙂

Now y’all know half of the stuff I write, I write it as reminders to myself. This is one of those but if it speaks to you, too, then come on and give this kindred spirit a hug! 

OOH! Let’s make divinity! 

Cream Cheese Divinity - A new no-fail take on Divinity! You won't believe how easy this is!

You’ll need: Cream Cheese (check out our recipe for easy-peasy homemade cream cheese), Butter (Margarine works, too), Confectioner’s Sugar, Lemon Juice, and Pecan halves*.

*You can also use pecan pieces and just mix them up in the dough if you like.

Cream Cheese Divinity - A new no-fail take on Divinity! You won't believe how easy this is!

Make sure your cream cheese and butter are at room temp. Whenever I have to make a recipe like this, I usually put them on the counter before I go to bed and then make it in the morning.

Place cream cheese, butter, and lemon juice in a mixing bowl.

Cream Cheese Divinity - A new no-fail take on Divinity! You won't believe how easy this is!

Mix those up really good with an electric mixer and then add a bit of vanilla.

Cream Cheese Divinity - A new no-fail take on Divinity! You won't believe how easy this is!

Now you need to add your sugar. You really should add the sugar gradually as you beat it.

Do I add it gradually? Yes, I do.

It’s just that my definition of “add gradually” means “dump it all in at once”.

Cream Cheese Divinity - A new no-fail take on Divinity! You won't believe how easy this is!

Get it all mixed up good, scraping down the sides as needed, until smooth and fully blended.

Now you are pretty much done. All that is left is shaping it into balls and pressing a pecan into each one.

See how easy?

Cream Cheese Divinity - A new no-fail take on Divinity! You won't believe how easy this is!

Roll them into little 1 inch balls and dip the bottoms into confectioner’s sugar.

You can skip this step but it makes them so much easier to deal with later and helps dry them out.

Cream Cheese Divinity - A new no-fail take on Divinity! You won't believe how easy this is!

Put all of the little balls onto wax paper or parchment.

Cream Cheese Divinity - A new no-fail take on Divinity! You won't believe how easy this is!

Press a pecan into each. Allow to sit out for a few hours to dry. After an hour or so, I flip them over to get the bottoms dry. after they have dried out and are no longer sticky (this will be 2-3 hours), put them in tins or plastic containers and store at room temp if they’ll be eaten in a day or two or in the fridge for a week or two.

Cream Cheese Divinity - A new no-fail take on Divinity! You won't believe how easy this is!

 Enjoy!

Cream Cheese Divinity

Cream Cheese Divinity is my own creation, born out of my love for traditional divinity! Anyone can make this no cook divinity.
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 5 minutes
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Keyword: creamcheese
Servings: 4
Calories: 342kcal

Ingredients

  • 8 ounce softened cream cheese at room temp
  • 3 tablespoons butter softened at room temp
  • 7-8 cups powdered sugar I buy a 2 lb bag
  • 1 tablespoon lemon juice
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla

Instructions

  • Place cream cheese, butter, and lemon juice in a mixing bowl. Beat with an electric mixer until fluffy.
  • Add in vanilla and gradually add in sugar (beginning with 7 cups), beating until all is well blended. Add more sugar if needed to make it a thick cookie dough consistency.
  • Once well blended, shape into 1 inch balls and dip bottoms into confectioner's sugar before placing on waxed paper or parchment. Press a pecan half into each one. Allow to dry for 2-3 hours and then store in a sealed container on the countertop if they will be eaten within a day or two, or in the fridge to keep up to 2 weeks.

Makes 50-60 pieces

    Nutrition

    Calories: 342kcal
    Tried this recipe?Mention @southernplate or tag #southernplate!

    “Honesty and integrity are absolutely essential for success in life – all areas of life. The really good news is that anyone can develop both honesty and integrity.”

    ~Zig Ziglar

    This recipe featured on Meal Plan Monday and Weekend Potluck

    Similar Posts

    99 Comments

    1. I made these tonight as a finger food for the football game….didn’t turn out. I followed the recipe to a tee but the divinity never dried out. It’s been 5 hrs now and they are as gooey now as they were after mixing it all up. I don’t know what went wrong but I hate when a recipe doesn’t work out. It’s money in the trash. Oh well…

    2. These were wonderful! Didn’t have pecans, so I followed the advice of one of the women here who said she used crushed candy canes instead…they are delicious and have a very pretty pink color! Everyone is enjoying them. Thanks for the recipe, Christy! :)))

    3. I made these this evening. The only problem with mine was that the “dough” was too sticky. I solved the situation by rolling the balls in powdered sugar to form them. This was an easy recipe to make. Thanks for the recipe.

    4. I was excited to see this recipe on Pinterest. My grandmother made divinity, my mother uses divinity icing on a German chocolate cake for our birthday cakes, but my grandmother also used divinity for Peanut Butter Roll. I wanted to try something that used natural sugar substitutes, so I got the confectioners version of Swerve. I didn’t use as much as you call for in the recipe of the powdered sugar. My estimate on the Swerve was about 4 1/2 cups. Also, I used Unsweetened Almond milk in place of the lemon juice. I was able to make a run of Peanut Butter Roll with it and I’m excited. Thanks for sharing this recipe with us. I’ll pass along the link with my modifications to those who want a sugar free version.

    5. Hi Christy. I made these, as I told you yesterday. However, I used my cookie dough scoop and only got 32 out of the recipe. Am wondering if I should have made them even smaller than 1″.

      1. Hmmm, that’s a quandry. When I make these it just seems like they go on and on and on until I am finally done with all the dough. My cookie dough scoop must be slightly smaller than yours or yours slightly larger. I’d just make the size that feels about right to you, but if you want more, certainly smaller wouldn’t hurt 🙂

      2. I quickly switched from a soup spoon to a teaspoon. I didn’t count, but maybe got 5-6 dozen. They are perfectly sized for a long narrow pecan half.

    6. Never made the Divinty before looking forward to trying this….and it looks great….. some good recipes here Christy, thanks for posting them….

      We make Pecan Tarts for Christmas and they are delicious…….kinda time consuming, but so worth it…..

    7. I love these! So so so much easier than divinity! I love your site and enjoy your blogs and recipes! Thank you for being you!

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe or Post Rating